The Hawaii Independent

Comment: Oahu pays high price for bad APEC deal

Comment: Oahu pays high price for bad APEC deal
A rare view from inside of the APEC conference: U.S. President Barack Obama answers questions on stage in front of the world's leading business executives.
Eric Gill
Nov 16, 2011 - 03:54 PM

Eric Gill is the Financial Secretary-Treasurer of UNITE HERE Local 5. A shortened version of the following column was featured in The Honolulu Star-Advertiser.


HONOLULU—Oahu residents are groaning under the impact of the Asia Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) conference. Parks and beaches were inaccessible or closed on a holiday weekend to residents and visitors alike. Roads were blocked unexpectedly and even the freeway closed, forcing commuters into massive traffic snarls. Businesses, too, closed because customers couldn’t get to their doors. Waikiki was under martial law conditions with concrete barricades, car searches, workers subject to background checks to determine if they could work, security passes needed to enter various areas, and even offshore surf sites closed.

Adding insult to injury, right after teachers and other public workers have been forced to take pay and benefit cuts, millions of dollars of our tax money was spent to spiff up landscaping and push our most unfortunate out of what little they can call home. 

This our government did in order to put on a show for the richest of the rich and their politician servants—the very ones who caused (and benefitted from) the economic crisis that has cut our services, impoverished our public workers, and put our families out on the street.

Whether or not Hawaii’s visitor industry will get a boost in business travel out of this is debatable, but one thing is certain: We have tainted the vacations of the visitors we already have. Just imagine paying for an expensive vacation in Waikiki and not being able to get in and out to see the sights or go golfing.

And all for what? Just what went on at the APEC talks that was worth the nuisance and expense we endured?

It’s all a big secret, but the facts are beginning to emerge despite the secrecy, and the distraction of self-promoting politicians making speeches. APEC was really about working on a dirty deal to benefit global banks and corporations at the expense of the rest of us. The Trans-Pacific Partnership (TPP) deal they continue to cook up represents a massive corporate/bank end-run around our laws, protections, rights, and self-determination.

Calling this kind of international agreement a “free trade” agreement is a cruel deception. Only a small portion of these agreements even talk about trade issues. Most of the provisions provide ways for global banks and corporations to get around the laws and regulations that we have set up to protect the public interest.

Labor laws to ensure basic standards for workers in our community? They are talking about how to get around those. Environmental protection laws, consumer protection laws, land-use laws, even laws to control health care costs—they are talking about how to get around those.

Laws protecting Hawaiian lands are in danger, rendering Hawaiian sovereignty meaningless, but it is not only Hawaii’s native peoples’ sovereignty that is being undermined, it is the sovereign rights of Hawaii and the United States as well.

All nations signing trade deals like the TPP are giving up sovereignty rights to corporations and banks.  The provisions of this agreement allow private entities—banks and corporations—to bring suit in international courts to enforce the terms. Global banks and corporations that have no allegiance or loyalty to any nation are empowered to bring lawsuits to force nations that sign the agreement to give up laws they have on the books that restrict banks and corporations from despoiling communities for profit.

This has already happened under previous “free trade” scams like the North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA). One recent example is how Mexican corporations have been successful in ignoring safety and anti-pollution laws that took decades of struggle to put in place. Unsafe and polluting Mexican trucks, with drivers paid under Mexican wage and benefit standards, now have free access to American highways, competing with American truckers that respect American laws.

Even future laws we would like to pass will be prevented. For example, the Governor’s idea that Hawaii should buy food from local farmers to feed out school children—that idea could be prevented along with any other Buy Hawaii or Buy American programs. The many good ideas that our community might come up with to build up our local economy and protect our local people could all be prevented or overturned in the false name of “free trade.”

Perhaps the most disgusting aspect of what is being discussed are the provisions that would make it impossible for Hawaii (or the United States and any signatory country) to control health care costs resulting from skyrocketing prescription drug prices. They are talking about rules that would prevent us from promoting generic drugs and force us to buy hideously overpriced patented drugs. And they want to extend the years that pharmaceutical companies can keep new drugs under patent, thereby maintaining their breathtaking monopoly prices for drugs.

Agreements such as TPP would make health care reform meaningless by taking away our ability to control the cost of prescription drugs, a major cost-driver in spiraling health care costs. All of us—or at least 99 percent of us—will be the victims, and the big pharmaceutical companies and the banks that own them. The 1 percent will generate even bigger profits off our illnesses and aging.

What APEC was talking about was a massive sellout by our political leaders to the 1 percent—the banks and corporations whose greed and incompetence has already crashed our economy and ruined the lives of millions in Hawaii and the United States. The TPP is just another scheme to stick it to the 99 percent of us that work for a living.

No wonder APEC put up walls, barricades, traffic stops and road closures to keep Hawaii’s people away from them. They were up to no good.

Background & Related Stories

Background

APEC 2011

The Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) is a 21-nation club of primarily industrialized or emerging economies. It was conceived in 1996, just as free-market deregulations and trade liberalizations were fostering economic advantages to industrialized nations, when there first emerged a greater consolidation of corporate power across nations, creating international legally binding policies that asserted less government regulations by weakening the labor force and dismantling environmental protections.

APEC member economies include Australia, Brunei, Canada, Indonesia, Japan, Republic of Korea, Malaysia, New Zealand, Philippines, Singapore, Thailand, United States, Chinese Taipei, Hong Kong, People’s Republic of China, Mexico, Papua New Guinea, Chile, Peru, Russia, and Vietnam.

To view the City’s APEC services information page, click here

APEC’s 21 member economies today account for 55 percent of global GDP, purchase 58 percent of U.S. goods exports, and comprise a market of 2.7 billion consumers. Seven of America’s top 15 trade partners are in APEC.

Proponents for APEC-related globalization efforts claim that by increasing international trade, it promotes diversity and multiculturalism, benefiting the third world by raising living standards and promoting democracy.

A major area of concern for activists is the negotiation of a Trans-Pacific Partnership Agreement (TPPA). Nine APEC countries, but not the full 21 members, are in negotiations over this trade treaty. The nine countries are the United States, New Zealand, Australia, Peru, Singapore, Vietnam, Peru, Malaysia, Chile, and Brunei. China and Japan are currently considering signing the TPPA.

From November 9-11, running concurrent with the 2011 APEC meeting in Honolulu, a group of activists is a counter-conference called Moana Nui. Notable scholars and activists such as Walden Bello from the Philippines, Jane Kelsey from New Zealand, and Lori Wallach of Public Citizen along with cultural practitioners from across the Pacific will discuss alternatives to corporate-led globalization.

For information on Moana Nui, visit moananui2011.org.

Related Stories

Everyday people: Hawaii Institute for Human Rights director localizes a global process to civility
Jan 04 2011 by Beth-Ann Kozlovich
Opening Day 2011: Lawmakers champion solidarity in tackling Hawaii’s big issues
Jan 20 2011 by Hawaii Independent Staff
“You need to be told the truth about where the city is right now – It is not pretty.”
Feb 24 2011 by Hawaii Independent Staff
Hawaii’s homeless plan: Are we in this for the long haul or not?
May 23 2011 by Beth-Ann Kozlovich
Letter: ‘Homeless’ people are still people
Jul 26 2011 by Letter to the Editor
Downtown Neighborhood Board to discuss rail, noise, reapportionment
Aug 01 2011 by Hawaii Independent Staff
Honolulu Mayor travels to Japan on goodwill tour
Aug 02 2011 by Hawaii Independent Staff
Tent city: Hawaii ‘homeless’ efforts must be long term, for the right reasons
Aug 09 2011 by Beth-Ann Kozlovich
Twelve reasons Hawaii should lead in social studies education
Aug 12 2011 by Mara Miller
City bill proposes public video surveillance during APEC
Aug 25 2011 by Hawaii Independent Staff
APEC surveillance: Do we care?
Sep 07 2011 by Jamie Winpenny
Filling the tourist hole: Industry buffs look to big spenders from far away
Sep 26 2011 by Beth-Ann Kozlovich
Globalizing the islands: The impact of APEC
Oct 14 2011 by Umi Perkins
World Invitational Hula Festival changes venue
Oct 18 2011 by Hawaii Independent Staff
The APEC hook: When the shark guards the tuna (Part 1)
Oct 18 2011 by Arnie Saiki
City announces Honolulu’s ‘APEC plan’
Oct 20 2011 by Hawaii Independent Staff
The APEC hook: Small fish in a big ocean (Part 2)
Oct 21 2011 by Arnie Saiki
The APEC hook: Hawaii bites (Part 3)
Oct 25 2011 by Arnie Saiki
APEC security delays holiday camping permits
Oct 26 2011 by Hawaii Independent Staff
City issues sewer work traffic advisory
Oct 31 2011 by Hawaii Independent Staff
APEC security restricts traffic cam access
Oct 31 2011 by Hawaii Independent Staff
HPD announces more City parks and facilities closures for APEC security
Nov 02 2011 by Hawaii Independent Staff
Hawaii taxpayers foot the bill: Is APEC business our business?
Nov 03 2011 by Beth-Ann Kozlovich
Occupy Honolulu encampment begins tonight
Nov 05 2011 by Ikaika M Hussey
Arrested Occupy Honolulu members seek community support
Nov 07 2011 by Hawaii Independent Staff
Shooting adds to local tension, APEC protesters call for justice
Nov 08 2011 by Hawaii Independent Staff
Protestors march for justice for shooting victim, against APEC
Nov 08 2011 by Jamie Winpenny
APEC traffic woes can be avoided
Nov 10 2011 by Jamie Winpenny
APEC: Who really wins?
Nov 11 2011 by Arnie Saiki
Richard Heinberg says conflict, non-growth will be the result of APEC’s agenda
Nov 14 2011 by Beth-Ann Kozlovich
Comment: Oahu pays high price for bad APEC deal
Nov 16 2011 by Eric Gill
Comment: The ‘burden of reality’ in high profile court cases falls on you
Nov 21 2011 by Beth-Ann Kozlovich
Christopher Deedy pleads not guilty in fatal shooting of Kollin Elderts
Nov 21 2011 by Jamie Winpenny
State says it spent less than expected on APEC
Nov 23 2011 by Hawaii Independent Staff
Students find a safe route to school
Should Hawaii prisons decide who may marry?
OHA subsdiary to suspend operations at Makaweli Poi Mill this month
Mayor launches “Pathways,” a transitional housing project for urban houseless
Abercrombie releases $37.5 million to address storm damage, safety upgrades